Ich

10.2.2. Ich in far more depth

As in most of the articles on this website, the subject of ich will be discussed in layers. The simplest explanation is first, followed by a series of more complicated explanations. Then we have another series of links to articles on the topic of ich in even greater depth.

Summary on Ich

MYTHBUSTER: ALL the well-done scientific studies by researchers on heat and ich have found heat to be totally ineffective in treating ich!

Note there are two other diseases that look like ich (tetrahymena in livebearers and epistylis in other fish). So make sure you have ich.

Public Aquariums use formalin/malachite green (Ich-X, Rid-Ich Plus, Blue Planet White Spot Remedy, AquaCare Anti-Fungus & White Spot, and Mardel QuickCure) to treat ich in freshwater fish, as do University Research Centers, Cory of Aquarium Co-op, and Joey.

Note:

  • NEVER turn off the filter, remove the filter, change the filter media or clean the filter media. If the carbon has been in the aquarium for more than two weeks do NOT remove it (contrary to some directions). This is VERY important.
  • Do NOT move the fish to a quarantine tank (contrary to some directions).
  • Formalin and malachite green are both toxic in large enough dosages so carefully follow the dosage directions on the medication bottle.
  • If one raises the temperature with formalin/malachite green the medication can become somewhat toxic.
  • Cory and others have treated thousands of “scaleless” fish with full-strength formalin medication with absolutely no problem.
  • Formalin/malachite green is not poisonous to snails or shrimp at the proper dosage.
  • At 76 °F (24,5 °C) formalin and malachite green need to be added every day to be effective.
  • Follow the directions on the medication as to water changes.
Ich
Ich

The seminal study on ich treatments (Tieman and Goodwin, 2001) found salt (0.25%) and heat to have no effect on ich. Other studies say 0.5% to 1% salt can reduce mortality from ich but is not as effective as medication. UV sterilizers, even at low wattages, can help immensely to eliminate ich from the aquarium.

Established filters have thousands of little carnivorous critters in them which eat the infectious ich stage (the “theront”), so the filter is very important. The net result of this filter “medication” is that if you have a long-established aquarium filter with plenty of brown “gunk” in it, it is perfectly OK to do absolutely nothing for the ich. It will simply go away on its own in a week or two.

Because ich will go away in an established aquarium, there are at least 55 “treatments” currently “absolutely guaranteed” to stop ich. There is an old saying in science: “Correlation does not imply causation”. ANY treatment of ich in a tank with an established filter will work. The ashes from the cremation of a dead squirrel will work to remove ich in a tank with an established filter

Ich on a Hap
Ich on a Hap

Treating Ich

On social media EVERYONE and I mean EVERYONE will tell you to raise the temperature up to 86 °F (30 °C) to treat ich. Researchers have shown heat to be totally ineffective in treating ich. This is simply one of the hundred or so myths commonly parroted by well-intentioned but ill-informed hobbyists in social media.

All discussions of treating ich in the aquarium must be predicated on the fact that medication is not as important in treating ich in the aquariums as everyone thinks. The aquarium filter is the most important aquarium “medication” for ich. The infectious free-swimming infectious stage of ich (the “theronts”) are literally eaten by a host of microscopic carnivores in the “brown gunk” of an established filter. This is the major mechanism treating ich in the home aquarium.

Most cases of ich will resolve themselves with no fatalities in most established home aquariums because of the brown gunk carnivores. One poor Facebook commentator had ich pop up. Following a common recommendation, he set up an “emergency” hospital tank with a new filter and put the infected fish into it. He took the temperature up and added some salt. All the fish died! This must have been incredibly disheartening. He had removed the fish from their established filter and used a relatively ineffective medication. Not a good idea.

Ich on a Mikrogeophagus
Ich on a Mikrogeophagus

As mentioned above, formalin/malachite green medications (Ich-X, Rid-Ich Plus, Blue Planet White Spot Remedy and Mardel QuickCure) are simply the best medications for ich.

If one is in Europe formalin is not available. There are three medications that will work reasonably well in place of formalin/malachite green are pure malachite green, methylene blue and copper. Brand names of these medications are Cupramine, Copper Power, Copper Aide, ESHA 2000, Copper Safe, Waterlife Protozin (Malachite Green and Copper) or Waterlife Myxacin (Malachite Green and acriflavine). Note that the formulations on European fish medications seem to change very often so check the labels.

There are also two other methods of controlling ich. One can add one or more wavemakers. The ich theront has difficulty attaching to the fish when the rate of water flow over the skin of the fish is high. One can also add a flow-through UV sterilizer. A flow-through UV sterilizer can be just as effective as an established filter at killing the ich theronts and controlling an ich outbreak.

And salt in a concentration of 5,000 to 7,500 ppm can somewhat help control an ich outbreak.

ich, white spot or ick
ich, white spot or ick

Proper Diagnosis of Ich

It is important to make sure one actually has a case of ich. “White spots” are not always ich. Warm freshwater tropical fish rarely die from ich. If fish with white spots are dying in an aquarium with a filter with brown gunk in it, suspect another disease pathogen. If fish are in an aquarium with a filter with brown gunk in it and have spots for more than one week with treatment with formalin/malachite green, suspect another pathogen.

Ich has very well-defined, very white spots only the size of a grain of salt, no larger. If the spots are not VERY well defined and VERY white, it is often another organism. Ich also occurs over the entire body of the fish (except the eyes) very uniformly. It never occurs in patches.

ich, white spot or ick
ich, white spot or ick

Epistylis

The most common ich imitator is called epistylis. The surprising thing is that at least 60% of the photos shown on social media from newcomers to the hobby as “obviously ich” are clearly epistylis. Epistylis appears to be more common in a relatively new aquarium than ich!

If it is goldfish, cichlids or loaches which are dying from “white spots” it is generally a bacterial columnaris infection that has a secondary infestation of this epistylis organism. The bacteria is killing the fish and the epistylis looks like ich. Since most hobbyists raise the temperature of the water to treat ich and bacteria become very virulent at high temperatures, the distinction is very important.

This is what epistylis looks like (note the spots on the eyes and the lack of spots on the head wen, ich generally won’t do this):

Epistylis
Epistylis

Epistylis is more variable and patchy than ich. It is translucent rather than ceiling white. And the spots stick out into the water, unlike ich which is always very embedded in the skin of the fish and will only stick out a little bit into the water.

IchEpistylis
Uniform round sizeVarying rough sizes
Pure ceiling whiteTranslucent gray/white
Flat against fishSticks out into water
All fish surfaces will have dotsPatchy coverage on fish
Rarely on the eyesCommon on the eyes
Rarely killsCommonly kills rapidly
Ich versus Epistylis

For more on epistylis, go to this link:

10.2.4. Epistylis

Note that there are no absolutes here. Here is an Oscar with ich where the ich is on the eyes.

Ich, ick or “white spot”
Ich, ick or “white spot”

Tetrahymena

If one has live bearers which are dying with “white spots”, almost always the culprit is another organism called Tetrahymena. Tetrahymena can look exactly like ich, needing a microscope to differentiate it from ich. Most of the time Tetrahymena is a somewhat variable dot that isn’t ceiling white, rather it is more a translucent gray.

This is a fish with Tetrahymena:

Tetrahymena
Tetrahymena
IchTetrahymena
Uniform round sizeVarying rough sizes
Pure ceiling whiteTranslucent gray
Flat against fishFlat against fish
All fish surfaces will have dotsCommon as a forehead white patch
Ich versus Tetrahymena

Tetrahymena is almost always is indicative of water with a high bacterial count. Added very good biofiltration is the only good solution. Tetrahymena is especially prevalent among guppies and other livebearers. Tetrahymena is called the “guppy killer” with good reason. It is often fatal. For more about tetrahymena go to this link:

10.2.6. Tetrahymena

Fish Lice

There is a type of small white fish louse that attaches to the fins and skin of fish. This can look like ich. The fish lice are harmless and typically disappear in a few months. They occur in short lines and patches, unlike ich.

a small fish louse
a small fish louse

And occasionally there is a viral skin infection called lymphocystis which mimics ich a little. A relatively small patch of a fish’s skin will slowly develop small nodules or circular bumps. Typically only one fish has it. The nodules go on to develop into the pink cauliflower growths so typical of lymphocystis.

For more on lymphocystis go to this link:

10.8. Lymphocystis

What does Ich Look Like

Here are several examples of fish that have ich. These fish all have the “looks like sprinkles of table salt” look to them, which is indicative of ich.

three fish with ich
three fish with ich

Ich spots need to be ceiling white and very circular. They are only the size of a grain of salt, no larger. They also almost never occur on the eyes and they are always evenly distributed over the fins and the body. Ich spots are embedded in the skin of the fish and only slightly protrude into the water.

Four fish with ich
Four fish with ich

Treating Ich

To treat ich the Universities of Florida, Kentucky, Mississippi, Arkansas and Southern Illinois and the USDA recommend formalin/malachite green in combination (Ich-X, Rid-Ich Plus, White Spot Remedy and Mardel QuickCure). They also recommend formalin (NT Labs Koi Care Formaldehyde). The universities also recommend copper (Cupramine, Copper Power, Copper Aide, Ichonex, ESHA 2000 or Copper Safe).

Public aquariums use formalin or formalin/malachite green for ich in freshwater fish and copper in saltwater (Hadfield, 2011). For cost reasons most aquaculture users will use copper for freshwater ich.

Cory at Aquarium Co-op (one smart young man who know his stuff and NEVER steers one wrong!) has used Ich-X (formalin and malachite green) successfully for ten years on hundreds of tanks and thousands of fish (he owns a fish store!). Joey Mullens of DIY fishkeepers also uses Ich-X.

ich
ich

It is important to note what the authorities above DO NOT USE when treating ich. They do not add salt (salt at a concentration of 0.5% to 0.75% will kill ich but not as well as formalin /malachite green does). They do not raise the temperature (raising the temperature simply does not work). Nor do they add any of the some 50 remedies “guaranteed” to cure ich such as Paraguard, Melafix, Pimafix or Herbtana.

Note that the idea that “scaleless” fish need a half dose is a myth. All fish do just fine with a full dose. Lots of full-strength medications like copper are used in raising catfish for food and they don’t die, even though they are “scaleless”. Two owners of fish stores and acknowledged experts on fishkeeping (Vicki of Freshwater Aquariums and Cory of Aquarium Co-op) have both treated thousands of scaleless fish with full strength formalin medications with no problems.

If you have invertebrates (snails, shrimp) the copper will kill them, so the only medication which is “safe” is formalin and formalin malachite green combination (note that formalin is toxic to EVERYTHING if overdosed but doesn’t work at half doses, so it is very touchy with regards to dosage). Copper is also dangerous in very soft water (GH< 4).

Note that the filter in the aquarium is the best defense against ich. So a well filtered aquarium will allow ANY treatment to work well. Also note I count at least 50 different “things” “guaranteed” to cure ich. If you believe any of these is better than what the University’s or public aquariums recommend and use, go for it.

ich on an aquarium fish
ich on an aquarium fish

Myths About ich

Like all things in the aquarium hobby, ich has some myths associated with it:

  • Heat treats ich, OR raising the temperature over 85 °F (30 °C) kills the ich organism. OR raising the temperature above 85 °F (30 °C) makes the ich organism incapable of reproducing.
  • Stress from things like poor water quality, poor diet, overcrowding, and being picked on by tank mates cause ich
  • Fish can’t become immune to ich and can get it multiple times.
  • Ich often kills many fish in a tank
  • “Natural” remedies like garlic, Melafix or Pimafix have an effect on ich
  • No less than 50 ineffective “ich cures” touted by various manufacturers will kill ich.
  • Ich cannot survive in an aquarium where there is no fish for longer than four weeks

All These Myths are False

If one goes to the links below one will find well done scientific studies with controls that prove these points to be myths.

Ich
Ich

Belief Perseverance Effect

Be aware that if you go on social media and try to dispel these myths, you will meet incredible resistance. As in all things, the hobbyists who believe these myths are very strong in their beliefs. That’s just human nature. Despite all the journal articles from universities in the linked articles below on ich saying these myths are false, these hobbyists will continue to believe these myths. This is called “belief perseverance effect” and is something which is useless to try and overcome.

“Nothing dies harder than a lie that people want to believe”

Calvin

One Facebook moderator said of this article:

“These are opinions with no scientific proof.

The link provided has no science behind it.

No controls and plenty of gaps.

Period.”

Interesting. Either this individual has an extreme case of “belief perseverance effect” or they chose not to read the scientific research articles with controls which support the data above.

“Ignorance is Bliss”

Ich in more Depth

Ich is the most common fish disease and warrants a more in-depth discussion. These discussions are long and boring and only for real nerds, like the author. The following chapters are devoted to this common fish disease:

10.2.2.1. Ich in More Depth

10.2.2.2. Immunity of Fish to Ich

10.2.2.3. Ich Medications

10.2.2.4. Ich Medications in More Depth

10.2.2.5. Ineffective Ich Medications

10.2.2.6. Using Filtration to Remove Ich

10.2.2.7. Treating Ich with Heat


Startpage Aquariumscience

Source: Aquariumscience.org – David Bogert

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Searchfilter
zoekfilter

Neuws, Updates en Promotions

Would you like to be kept informed of News, Updates and Promotions on the AquaInfo website? Subscribe below!