4.2. Aquarium temperatures

The temperature of an aquarium is much less important than hobbyists give it credit for. Most freshwater tropical fish live quite comfortably at the temperature of most homes (65 ⁰ to 85 ⁰ F, 18 ⁰ to 30 ⁰ C). And, contrary to popular mythology, temperature fluctuations do not hurt tropical fish. In nature, the temperature of layers of water varies radically and fish swim through those thermoclines with no damage.

The recommended general temperatures for fish are (Fahrenheit):

For those outside the US, this table in Celsius is more useful:

Don’t take too much liberties with this table. Some tropical fish will die rapidly when presented with water below 60 ⁰ F. And the “acceptable excursions” temperature ranges should be considered temporary excursion temperatures, not permanent living conditions. The Amazon table includes some blackwater fish from Asia, like the Clown Botia.

Note that Cory of Aquarium Coop (a bright young guy who NEVER steers one wrong!) did another great YouTube video where he explains why all tropical fish do just fine all the way down to 65 (18 C) degrees. He points out that fish farms in South Florida routinely hit temperatures of 65 degrees Fahrenheit (18 C) in the water of the ponds for extended periods of time (days) and the fish are fine.

Cory has kept community tropical tanks at room temperature without a heater for many years in his house at down to 65 degrees (18 C). So the idea that ANY tropical fish “requires” 79 degrees F. (26 C) or higher at all times is simply hogwash.

One study on three species of Amazonian corydoras has the building heat go out inadvertently. The water temperature went down to 57 degrees Fahrenheit (14 degrees Celsius). Only 20% of the corydoras perished (“Effects of salinity on distribution, growth and survival of three neotropical armored catfishes”, (Siluriformes—Callichthyidae)”, Jan H. Mol, 1994).

Another study took a large number of juvenile discus from 82°F (28°C) to 57°F (14)°C at a speed of one degree per hour. Apparently, no discus died since the paper reported no fatalities. (“Sensitivity in the Antioxidant System of Discus Fish (Symphysodon 2 spp.) to Cold Temperature: Evidence for Species-specific Cold Resistance”, Shi-Rong Jin et. al. , 2013) , 2013)

And there is no evidence that, in a tropical aquarium, ich is prevented by keeping the temperature high. What is known is that fish live shorter lives at 83 °F(28°C) than they will at 73°F (23°C).

Aquarium Heating

There are constant sad situations on social media where the heater stuck in an aquarium and cooked the fish. In many situations the temperature rose to the point the owner could not touch the water. That is a seriously overpowered heater. Per aquarium equipment suppliers the “basic rule of thumb is 3-5 watts per gallon”. Once again, the profit motive at work. Three to five watts of power per gallon can raise the temperature of the water by 30 to 40°F (16 – 22°C) and cook the fish. Any heater that can do this is obviously very over-sized.

The “basic rule of thumb for aquarium heaters should be “have redundancy, such as two small heaters”. One should use two low wattage heaters for most aquariums in homes. For every 10°F (5°C) the tank temperature ABSOLUTELY NEEDS to be raised one should use a MAXIMUM of:

There are also some electronic temperature controllers which cut out the power to the heaters when the water temperature hits a set temperature. They are an excellent investment. The redundancy these heater controllers provide is important.

Here is a link to an article about heaters:

14.8. Heaters

Stability

One very big and myth being parroted in seemingly endless comments in social media is that fish need “stability” in their temperature. Supposedly any rapid change over 2 degrees temperature will “shock”, “stress” and possibly kill the fish.

This idea is simply a myth, one of the many myths passed down by generations of aquarium owners. It is like saying humans will get a “cold” because they expose themselves to cold. In their native environment most fish are constantly subject to rapid and large changes in water temperature. These changes do not “shock” them.

Anyone who has ever taken a swim in a pond or a lake in the afternoon will tell you the water temperature at the surface can be considerably different from the water temperature just a few feet down. Any biologist familiar with freshwater lakes will tell you the temperature of the water changes constantly and amazingly quickly from one layer to another layer in the water. And fish swim up and down though these thermoclines constantly with no ill effects.

This is explored further in this link

4.8. Stability isn’t Important

Goldfish

There is one very commonly held myth needing quashing. Goldfish are not a cold-water fish, they are an “all water” fish. In South Florida there are thousands of ponds with goldfish and koi in them. These ponds get to 85⁰ to 90⁰F (29 to 32°C) for six months out of the year. And the goldfish and koi do just fine.

Here is a link to an article on goldfish:

17.5. Goldfish

One final caution. Never trust a water change to an inexperienced person in a cold winter. One cause of a whole aquarium dying is doing a large water change with 40°F (5°C) water.

.

Startpagina Aquariumscience

Bron: Aquariumscience.org – David Bogert