There is one type of foam sump that is VERY attractive to those who are cowed by the complexity or the noise of a fluidized bed sump. It is a foam/ 2 wavemaker sump. This is what it looks like:
This will have about 60% of the biofiltration capacity of the same volume K1 fluidized bed sump. It will be much easier to set up than the K1. It is much quieter than any of the fluidized K1 designs. If the sump is made very large compared to the bioload and a high protein food is fed, this sump design will never need maintenance.
The surface area of the coned red top piece of foam is very large and the two wavemakers ensure a large flow of well-oxygenated water over this large surface. These two factors ensure the top red piece of foam will never foul.
Let us go through a build for a 110-gallon heavily stocked mbuna aquarium. What is needed?
Bill of materials:
- 40-gallon breeder aquarium 17 inches high, 36 inches long, 18.25 inches wide.
- 3-inch thick 20 ppi foam red waffle 26×19.5 inch Poret foam sheet
- Two 4-inch thick 30 ppi blue 26×19.5 Poret foam sheets
- Thirty-gallon under-gravel filter
- Two side-by-side bladed circulation pumps
- Two acrylic sheets 18.25 by 13 inches in size, siliconed into the tank, 25.5 inches apart. No holes are needed in the acrylic
- High-Pressure Pump capable of lifting 5 feet of head.
This will give about 10x18x26=4,680 cubic inches 4,680 = 2.7 cubic feet of foam. At roughly 340 square feet per cubic foot of foam, this gives 918 square feet of media surface area. At 100 square feet per pound of fish, this is 9.2 pounds of fish. This is very roughly 7 adult Oscars, or 51 or so adult mbuna, which is HUGE. What might be more amazing is that a K1 fluidized bed in the same volume gives 12 adult Oscars and 78 adult mbuna.
The two-bladed circulation pumps at the surface in the 4 inches or so of free water space will aerate the water well, which is important. The bladed pumps will also keep the feces and large particulate matter agitated and broken up rapidly.
Do not use the undergravel lifts. Use ONLY the plates. And do not silicone the plates into place.
For more information on sumps click on the following links:
Note that many beginners are concerned about how to flow the water to a sump. The common refrain is “my aquarium isn’t drilled, how does the water get to the sump?” Click on this link to get some ideas:
Source: Aquariumscience.org – David Bogert